diff --git a/app/Models/Orders.php b/app/Models/Orders.php
index 5aaae3a..0769347 100755
--- a/app/Models/Orders.php
+++ b/app/Models/Orders.php
@@ -217,8 +217,9 @@ class Orders extends SoftDeletesModel
         return $this
             ->hasMany(Recharge::class, "order_id", "id")
             ->whereNotNull("paid_at")
-            ->select("id", "order_id", "manager_id", "serial", "money", "payment", "payment_serial", "remark", "created_at")
-            ->with("manager");
+            ->select("recharge.id", "recharge.order_id", "recharge.manager_id", "recharge.serial", "recharge.money", "recharge.payment", "recharge.payment_serial", "recharge.remark", "recharge.created_at")
+            ->leftJoin("managers", "managers.id", "=", "recharge.manager_id")
+            ->addSelect("managers.name as manager_name");
     }
 
     public function refunds()